Showing posts with label SEBI. Show all posts
Showing posts with label SEBI. Show all posts

Saturday, July 4, 2009

Portfolio management under Sebi scanner

The Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi), after tightening the norms for the mutual fund industry, is now looking at portfolio management services. The market regulator will soon be coming out stricter and comprehensive guidelines for PMS.
According to a senior banker with a leading foreign bank that offers wealth management and portfolio management services, Sebi has been in dialogue with several service providers to get their views on making the services more transparent and investor-friendly. "We have been deliberating with the regulator and it should be coming out with guidelines in the coming few weeks," the executive said on the condition of anonymity.
Earlier, a senior Sebi official has mentioned the watchdog is indeed looking at all areas for making things transparent and investor-friendly. According to industry sources, there are several aspects that the regulator is looking at and one important aspect is the PMS fees.
There are no restrictions now on fees charged by service providers. However, since the market is competitive, rates remain reasonable. "But there are instances of fee structures changing with the market trend. During the boom of 2007-08, some charged atrocious fees, and there were also some handsome profit sharing agreements," says a Mumbai-based broker. Hence, the regulator is expected to cap the fees charged by portfolio managers.
This, however, might not go down well with the 229-odd portfolio managers registered with Sebi. But rthe regulator isn't much worried about that. "In 1992, when we had asked brokers to disclose the fees they charge to clients, there was an uproar, and trading closed for four days, however, they had to comply and things are much better now," said the Sebi official.
Generally, portfolio managers have three schemes, one where a flat fee of around 2% of the portfolio amount is charged, and the service provided includes investment advice at regular intervals and managing the portfolio. The second scheme includes a fixed fee and a profit-sharing scheme, the latter usually kicks in when a return over the government bond (risk-free return) rate is crossed. Then, there is the totally variable scheme where the manager charges a total variable fee structure based on profit sharing.
The first two are said to be the more popular, and the third variety usually gains ground when the market is booming and is offered to high-ticket clients.
The norms are also expected to cover the 'wealth management' area. There are no specific norms now for this burgeoning industry that has several service providers like banks, brokers, financial service firms and individuals. Sebi has applied to the finance ministry to extend the definition of the term 'securities' in the Sebi Act to several instruments, especially alternative investments like those in art and several structured products that usually beat the definition and thereby the Sebi purview. Wealth managers are known to offer such products to their clients and there is usually an issue in the valuation of these instruments, noted a banker. They don't want a Madoff- like situation happening in India where exotic products are peddled to wealthy clients under Ponzi schemes, he adds.
The market size of PMS is estimated to around Rs 1 lakh crore. Sebi has been tightening the PMS norms over the years. In May 2008, Sebi had increased the networth requirement for portfolio managers from Rs 50 lakh to Rs 2 crore and also asked the portfolio managers not to pool accounts of clients. Pooling of clients would mean portfolio managers becoming quasi-mutual funds, not giving customised services.
On June 23, 2009, Sebi clarified that there should be a clear segregation of each client's fund through proper and clear maintenance of back-office records. It also mentioned that portfolio managers were not allowed to use funds of one client for another client. Portfolio managers will also have to maintain an accounting system containing separate client-wise data for their funds and provide statement to their clients for such accounts at least every month. Importantly, managers will have to reconcile client-wise funds with the funds in their bank account every day.

Transparency drive

#Sebi likely to set limits on fee charged by PMS providers

#Guidelines may cover 'wealth managers' as well

#Alternate assets like art, structured products under lens

#Emphasis on reporting asset position and charges likely

#Has already ordered separate client accounts and statement

Source

Tuesday, February 17, 2009

Stock Up On Essentials Of Equity Before Buying Stocks

Thinking of investing in stocks? Make sure you have the right attitude and know how to go about it. Here are some tips you must consider before trying your hand.
So you've made up your mind to invest in the stock market. Having overcome initial inhibitions, you're now looking to become a millionaire overnight. After all, if your friend A or your cousin B could do it, why not you?
For investment-innocents, here's a shocker: It is not where you invest your money, but how you invest it that decides the profits. That is to say, stocks are only as good as the investor; they respond to the individual's abilities and acumen. In that sense, stocks are quite distinct from consumer durables. You can reasonably expect a washing machine to perform as well for you as for your neighbour, but that is not the case for stocks, which are a different breed altogether.
So, instead of investment tips, here are some attitude tips.

Don't commit large amounts of money or short-term money.
Even if you can afford to take risks, we suggest you don't commit large sums of money-at least not in the initial stages. It would be wiser to start with small amounts and increase your investments as your confidence and grasp of the markets grows. It is not easy to pick up the right stocks or keep track of them when you are starting out.
Also, don't break FDs to invest in rising markets.
Always invest the surplus, money for which you have no immediate plans. Equity, as an investment, carries in-built risk and volatility and investing short-term money may force you to quit at the wrong time.
Do be sceptical of self-proclaimed experts.
As an investment ingénue, stay away from self-proclaimed experts or overzealous advisers. The so-called 'hot tips' they offer to investors are largely short-term trading tips, which are very risky for a retail investor. Because the reaction time is limited, chances are you will end up losing wealth.
Similarly, TV gurus and the like are forever ready with "buy" recommendations; few, if any, come out with "sell" advisories for your advantage.
Further, expert recommendations often have vested interests. Recently, market regulator Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) fined an expert for acting exactly contrary to his own recommendations. To curtail such rogue elements, the market regulator is planning a law to govern experts, who comment on the markets in the mass media.
Don't trade for short-term.
Short-term trading or day trading is very risky and not recommended for retail and small investors for two reasons. First, it requires lot of time, which small investors can rarely spare since it is not their primary business. Second, retail investors may not have the necessary skills and tools required for short-term and day trading. Do not try to time the markets: it's one of the most difficult things to do.
Invest long-term in fundamentally strong companies.
Our advice to retail investors is to invest long-term in fundamentally strong companies. Give your portfolio adequate time to grow. Do not panic in technical corrections. If you are invested in fundamentally strong companies, you are safe. We saw two sharp corrections in 2006, first in May-June and again in December. On both occasions, the market bounced back and crossed previous highs because the fundamentals were intact.
Don't ignore stock fundamentals.
There is no set formula for fundamental analysis. You have to study various indicators like sectoral growth, company growth-both top and bottomlines-and various ratios like price to earning ratio, price earning to growth, dividend yield, book value, price to book value, price to sales ratio, debt-equity ratio, return on capital employed, to name just a few.
If number-crunching is not your cup of tea, you must still investigate the nature, business and size of the company and its growth in the last three years-sales, profit and earning per share (EPS)-all of which are accessible on the websites of stock exchanges.
Do not be tempted to buy small caps and penny stocks.
The risk involved in small companies is huge, but higher risk may not necessarily lead to higher gain. That is not to say that you should ignore small companies completely, but at the same time you must have solid reasons for buying into them. And when you do, make sure they are only a small portion of your portfolio.
To be critical of media reports.
It's tempting, when you are just about beginning to follow the jargon, to buy into glowing media reports about corporates. But they could be misleading. For instance, you may read of a company setting up a new plant. Such announcements usually push up prices in anticipation of earning growth.
Before you join the queue for their stocks, you need to understand the cost benefit of the new plant. Ask yourself a few questions: where is the money coming from-equity or debt? If it's equity, how will it impact the EPS in the near future? If the source is debt, is the company in a position to leverage the increased debt? What will be the gestation period?
When will the earnings really start coming in?
What will be the return on capital employed?
Don't follow other investors blindly.
People often talk about their success in the stockmarket, rarely of their failures. Your friend may have made money in the past, but there's no guarantee he will continue to do so in future.
If, however, he offers to share his stocks research with you, welcome the opportunity. It will help you build your own research, but remember it is not a substitute for your own investigation.
Do stay away from a large number of stocks.
Investors generally hold a large number of stocks in the name of diversification. But this may not always be the case. Harry Markowitz, known as the Father of the Modern Portfolio, warned investors: "Holding securities that tend to move in concert with each other does not lower risk." A truly diversified portfolio, he said, comprises non-correlated asset classes that could provide the highest returns with the least amount of volatility.
If you are still looking to diversify within equity, do not go in for stocks of more companies than you can track regularly. Seven to 10 would be ideal, though, of course, this is a highly individual call. The biggest disadvantage of holding a large number of stocks is failing to quit at the right time.
Stocks are only as good as the investor-they respond to the individual's abilities and acumen
Source

Wednesday, February 11, 2009

Operation Satyam

Date:5 Feb 2009
When the government deputed a team of ace management professionals to take over charge at Satyam Computer after Founder B. Ramalinga Raju revealed his fraud, little did they know what awaited them. Who among the old crew should the new team trust? How should it keep the engine running and what course should it set? Come to think of it, why shouldn’t Satyam just be wound up? Working without any handbook, with every figure and bank balance having to be double checked, the new team has its work cut out. BT puts together an imaginary briefing of the new directors, by one of them, based on real interactions between E. Kumar Sharma and Satyam insiders.
So let’s look at the first: Why must Satyam go on?
Business continuity is important. as you know, we were checking out Satyam’s client list and found that Singapore’s Changi airport has a few things running on Satyam’s software. May be not mission critical, may be they can get others to do it, but I’m sure they can’t find a replacement overnight. So we’ve got to reassure clients like Changi that we are still here and they will get all the support they need. Satyam also does complete payroll processing for at least one South East Asian country. It serves about a dozen airlines by maintaining systems that determine pilot rotation and reporting of crew to different flights.
Good that we are making a list of all the top customers of Satyam and contacting each one individually to confirm that according to our books, this is the order we have from you, this is the work we are doing and this is the payment due from you. As you know, we found that there are some companies for which Satyam is the sole vendor.
So gentlemen, clearly, Satyam’s clients are its assets. Many are absolute marquee names and none of them has so far complained about the quality of our work.
Money, or the lack thereof!
Shocking, you know, that letter Raju wrote to his board on January 7. I mean, here’s a $2 billion company that was assumed to have huge cash reserves plus deposits and receivables and suddenly, nothing! The good news is that we cross-checked every account and found that Satyam has around $10-20 million of net cash in the bank. The bad news is that this is loose change for a company like Satyam. Maybe enough for a few days at the rate it burns cash. With over 50,000 employees on the payroll, we’ve got to ensure that we can pay them at the end of the month. (As BT went to print, it learnt that employees had started getting their pay credited into their accounts.)
All right, that brings us to item 3: How many employees does Satyam really have?
You know, i was shocked when the public prosecutor claimed that Raju had inflated headcount by 13,000 and was skimming the money! This was critical— we don’t want to end up paying salaries to people who don’t exist!
But we know now that there does not seem to be any basis for this claim… We did a pretty thorough check using different methods and despite the media reports we can say with a fair degree of confidence that the original figure is more or less true and really there are no fake employees. There may be some aberrations, but certainly nowhere near the figure of 13,000 being talked about. The numbers are valid. It’s not just the employee numbers— there were doubts on all data—on receivables, liabilities—whether the figures have been understated, overstated, were right or wrong. Or whether the customer names were real or just fictitious names against whom some orders were created.
That brings us to item 4, which is, how to restore trust.
After the fire-fighting steps, our first worry was how to restore trust… a bit unfair but it’s the truth, simply because of the scale of the fraud and that this was done for 5-6 years and you are talking of Rs 6,000-7,000 crore. It seems very difficult for any lay person to believe that there were just three people involved—the two Raju brothers and the CFO. It may be possible that it has all been done very cleverly but a common man will still say: it just can’t be. There must be more people involved. Well, if that’s true, one does not know who to trust within the company.
This is one reason why the board is not finding it easy to completely and fully believe any of the senior managers. But we are just six of us now for this huge multinational, so the current management is being allowed to run the company on the principle of ‘innocent till proven guilty.’ Well, it is also partly because it is fair and partly because there is no choice as one cannot do away with the top management without impacting business continuity.
As you know, we have identified around 300 top customers who account for at least 80 to 85 per cent of the revenues, and by the end of the month (January end) about 60 to 70 per cent of them would have been contacted and will know the actual figures by then.
For this, the board is taking the help of the newly appointed auditors, KPMG and Deloitte, who are also using their international contacts (as some of them are working for these same international clients outside India). All of this is important as payments are made 30 to 60 days after delivery.
Now for the medium and long-term future. We are an interim arrangement, and have to look for a CEO and CFO.
The trouble is, we don’t know the mandate for the new CEO, given that one of the strategic options being considered is the acquisition of Satyam by another company. If that happens, the new management will obviously appoint its own CEO. For the moment, while many people have volunteered to take up the task, the company and the board are not in a position to offer a term or spell out for how long the new CEO and CFO would be needed. Then, we are not clear about the salary package we should offer, and nor can we tell him that he will be protected from legal cases.
As for the other issues, we now have an investment banker to advice on the best way forward.
The questions are whether we should let it be acquired or whether we should split it into smaller pieces and look for separate buyers? Boston Consulting Group (BCG) is now our management advisors, and Goldman Sachs & Avendus the investment bankers. The board has no idea of how long it could take to reach a stage where things can move on its own but it is hoping to accomplish this in the next three to six months. There is little doubt today that the company has a very high probability of survival. For the moment, the company is getting over its fire fighting mode. The biggest fire was finding the money to pay salaries and that has been more or less resolved, not just for this month but also for the next 2-3 months. The focus is now on medium to long term and for this the role of investment banker becomes critical. The immediate necessity, at least for the short to medium term will be finding the new CEO and CFO, who are urgently and desperately required.
Source

Thursday, January 22, 2009

Sebi wants full promoter disclosures on pledging

The Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi), the capital markets regulator, on Wednesday made it mandatory for publicly traded companies to disclose any pledges of shares by their promoters, responding to mounting concerns over the risk of investing in such entities.
“Promoters who pledge shares have to disclose it to the company and the company, in turn, has to disclose it to the stock exchanges. If we get complaints that people are not complying with the regulation, we will investigate those complaints,” Sebi chairman C.B. Bhave said.
Promoters of listed firms routinely pledge their equity holdings discreetly to lenders, largely to raise personal loans, a practice that has heightened investment risk on Indian stocks and caused large investors to call for mandatory disclosures of such moves.
Such share pledges diluting the equity of founders could also lead to potential takeover situations.
Satyam Computer Services Ltd founder B. Ramalinga Raju, who confessed on 7 January to having committed accounting fraud to the tune of Rs7,136 crore, was found to have pledged almost all of his equity stake with private lenders to raise cash.
On Monday, Mint had reported that nearly $15 billion (Rs73,650 crore today) worth of promoter shares have been pledged as collateral with lenders, according to a dozen senior executives from the broking, banking and non-banking finance communities. These executives also said that such transactions had also been struck offshore with large global banks, and facilitated by private bankers, while in some cases funds were moved using an illegal money transfer system known as hawala.
The announcement by Sebi on Wednesday, made by chairman C.B. Bhave, aims to curb such practices. Under its new rules, companies are required to make both so-called event-based and periodic disclosures of pledging of shares by promoters.
Event-based announcements will be made as and when a promoter’s shares are offered as loan collateral, while periodic disclosures will require firms to report all such pledges at the end of every quarter.
Bhave did not make clear how these new rules would be implemented, only saying that the regulator would seek details of such activities as on 31 December 2008. He also did not specify a starting date for periodic declarations.
“We have decided to give them (promoters) time,” Bhave said.
Housing Development and Finance Corp. Ltd (HDFC) chairman Deepak Parekh, who has been appointed by the government to the Satyam board, said at an industry conference here on Wednesday that the move to tighten disclosure rules was a “good step forward”.
“It’s positive because in India just because you don’t want to reduce your family holding, you keep borrowing against your equity and keep growing because you don’t want to give up control on the company,” Parekh said.
Experts said promoters could skirt the regulations by exploiting loopholes.
An investment banker at a foreign brokerage noted that share pledges could take place at a holding company level. Holding companies are not required to make such disclosures. “Promoters will now take the transaction one level up,” this banker said.
At least three companies have adopted this structure, replacing the pledged shares of their publicly traded company with the shares they own in a holding company, the banker said, warning that many more could take this route.
Bhave, however, maintained that pledging shares in a holding company may not have the same impact (as pledging shares of publicly traded companies). “Let us first implement this and see what happens,” he said.
Also, in the near term at least, companies that make such disclosures will likely see a slide in their stock price, said analysts and fund managers.
“This will be considered as additional leverage on the company,” said Adrian Mowat, managing director and chief Asian and emerging market equity strategist at JPMorgan Securities (Asia Pacific) Ltd.
“An increasingly obvious risk (in India) is that entrepreneur-dominated companies are vulnerable because of heavy personal borrowing by these entrepreneurs against their own share prices,” wrote Christopher Wood of CLSA Asia-Pacific Markets in a 15 January Greed and Fear report.
The regulator also discussed the issue of peer review by independent auditors for large listed companies, but is undecided on the criteria for it. Bhave also declined to clarify whether the company or the regulator would pay for the additional audit.
The Sebi board also reviewed the progress made so far in the investigations into Satyam Computer.
“We cannot ascertain the size of the scam until investigations are over. We are investigating the books of Satyam to determine the bank deposits of the company. We have not been able to question Mr Raju, but we have gone to the auditors, internal finance department of the firm and questioned them,” Bhave said.
Source

Monday, October 13, 2008

Shaky markets? Dos and Don'ts for you!

With global markets, and especially the Indian stock market, at their most volatile, many market watches are making all sorts of doomsday scenarios.
When the BSE Sensex was at the stratospheric 21,000 levels in January 2008, everyone and their uncle wanted to buy stocks, come what may.
Now that the Sensex has fallen to 10,500 levels, the exuberance that had visited the markets then is visibly missing.
However, in the process many a small investor lost tons of money. While the big players could ride the storm and perhaps get out with some hurt, many small investors lost their life's savings when the markets crashed.
So what should investors do now? Well, here's a basic check list for you to follow.
Dos and Don'ts of investing in stocks
· With the markets crashing, it is natural for you to be unnerved, but panicking will not help. Actually it's a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to buy good stocks with strong fundamentals, but be very careful while doing so.
· Don't indulge in panic selling. Stay invested, it is time to buy stocks and not sell. Since very few people can predict market movement, NEVER try to time the market.
· To be on the safe side, invest in mutual funds, and don't listen to 'experts' who mushroom all of a sudden and are eager to give you formidable advice. If you are unsure about your research and is not too comfortable with your own judgement, MFs are your best bet.
However, there is a golden rule that applies to all and sundry. Regardless of what market experts tell you, it is critical to understand where you stand and where you want to be. Also, what level and amount of investment are you comfortable with. Therefore, take some time to evaluate your risk-bearing capacity.
· Now that you have decided to enter the market, maybe for the first time, do follow the following rules. It is imperative that you are aware of the traps and dangers of investing in stocks and exercise maximum caution.
What to do in the market
· Always deal with the market intermediaries registered with the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) / stock exchanges. Complete all the required formalities of opening an account properly (client registration, client agreement forms, et cetera).
· Always insist on contract notes from your broker. In case of doubt of the transactions, verify the genuineness of the same on the exchange Web site (http://www.bseindia.com / http://www.nseindia.com).
· Ask for and sign 'Know Your Client Agreement.'
· Read and properly understand the risks associated with investing in securities/derivatives before undertaking transactions.
· Assess the risk-return profile of the investment as well as the liquidity and safety aspects before making your investment decision.
· Ask all relevant questions and clear your doubts with your broker before transacting.
Invest, based on sound reasoning after taking into account all publicly available information and on fundamentals.
· Give clear and unambiguous instructions to your broker / agent / depository participant.
· Be vigilant in your transactions. Insist on a contract note for your transaction.
· Scrutinise minutely both the transaction and the holding statements that you receive from your Depository Participant.
· Keep copies of all your investment documentation.
Handle Delivery Instruction Slips (DIS) Book issued by DPs carefully. Insist that the DIS number are pre-printed and your account number (Client ID) is pre-stamped.
· In case you are not transacting frequently make use of the freezing facilities provided for your Demat Account.
· Always settle the dues through the normal banking channels with the market intermediaries.
· Before placing an order with the market intermediaries please check about the credentials of the companies, its management, its fundamentals and recent announcements made by them and various other disclosures made under various regulations. The sources of information are the websites of exchanges and companies, databases of data vendor, business magazines, et cetera.
· Deliver the shares in case of sale or pay the money in case of purchase within the time prescribed.
· Participate and vote in general meetings either personally or through proxy.
· Be aware of your rights and responsibilities.
· In case of complaints approach the right authorities for redressal in a timely manner.
Adopt trading / investment strategies commensurate with your risk-bearing capacity as all investments carry risk, the degree of which varies according to the investment strategy adopted.
· Please carry out due diligence before registering as client with any Intermediary. Further, investors are requested to carefully read and understand the contents stated in the Risk Disclosure Document, which forms part of investor registration requirement for dealing through brokers in the stock market.
· Be cautious about stocks, which show a sudden spurt in price or trading activity, especially low price stocks.
· Please be informed that there are no guaranteed returns on investment in stock markets
What NOT to do while investing in stocks
· Don't deal with unregistered intermediaries.
· Don't fall prey to promises of unrealistic returns.
· Don't invest on the basis of hearsay and rumours; verify before investment.
· Don't forget to take note of risks involved in the investment.
· Don't be misled by rumours circulating in the market.
· Don't be influenced into buying into fundamentally unsound companies (penny stocks) based on sudden spurts in trading volumes or prices or non-authentic favourable looking articles/stories.
· Don't follow the herd or play on momentum - it could turn against you.
· Don't be misled by so called 'hot tips.'
· Don't try to time the market.
· Don't hesitate to approach the proper authorities for redressal of your doubts/grievances.
· Don't leave signed blank Delivery Instruction Slips of your demat account lying around carelessly or with anyone.
· Do not sign blank Delivery Instruction Slips and keep them with Depository Participant or broker to save time. Remember your carelessness can be very dangerous.

Source

Monday, August 11, 2008

New payment system for IPOs by Aug 10: Bhave

A new payment system for Initial Public Offers that is aimed at not blocking investors' money till share are actually allotted will be launched as a pilot by August 10, stock market regulator SEBI said on Tuesday.
"Hopefully by end of August, we will start the pilot project," SEBI Chairman C B Bhave told reporters on the sidelines of a seminar on financial planning.
Initially, both the existing system of payment for public issues and the new alternate system will co-exist.
"We really don't know how the system works. We need to get used to it. We have to sort out glitches if there are any in the beginning," Bhave said.

Sunday, July 27, 2008

Avoiding the delisting trap

Avoiding the delisting trap
Rakesh Rai
July 25, 2008
Welcome once again to the dark side of stock markets. Despite the renewed focus on investor protection by regulators and stock exchanges, there are companies that continue to tap the market for funds and vanish without a trace or are struck off the exchange for violations. These delisted companies leave in their wake a trail of clueless investors who have been cheated out of a fair value of their investments.
While a massive delisting exercise took place in June 1995, when 209 companies were delisted, it happened again in April 1996 (87 companies) and February 1997 (168). In the latest such move by the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) in 2004, 885 out of a total of 5,500 listed companies were struck off. While some of these were profit-making companies, others had a healthy book value per share, and so could tap the stock market for funds again. But what about the nearly 10 lakh shareholders who had bought shares in these companies? A majority weren’t even aware of the exercise as the exchange is under no obligation under the Sebi (Delisting of Securities) Guidelines 2003 to tell them when companies delist or are delisted.
“The pathetic monitoring of listed companies, non-enforcement of financial penalties (up to Rs 25 crore) under the Securities Contract (Regulation) Act 1956 and mechanical delisting by BSE has rewarded corporate misgovernance at the cost of small investors,” says Virendra Jain who runs investorhelpline.in. It has received hundreds of complaints against firms delisted in 2004.
Delisting can take place in two ways—voluntary and compulsory. In case of the former, the promoters approach the exchange and are allowed to delist after they fulfill the specified Sebi guidelines. However, it is the compulsory delisting for noncompliance with the terms of the listing agreement that creates most problems for individual investors. The delisting process begins when the exchange issues a notice to the errant company. If it doesn’t respond or comply within a certain timeframe, the company is suspended. If it continues to play rogue for another six months, it can be delisted. But exchanges normally don’t follow the guidelines and give the company 3-5 years to comply before delisting it.The exchanges justify hauling up such firms, saying they are within their rights to ask them to conform to regulations that are meant to promote good investing practices. The companies are even granted a grace period to fall in line, they argue. And as most violations relate to non-payment of annual listing fee, the exchanges say that they are providing a commercial service for which they deserve to be compensated. For instance, the companies with a share capital of up to Rs 5 crore have to cough up an annual listing fee of not more than Rs 10,000. That is small change for any listed company and promoter.
Delisting is the final step in a long, winding tale. The problem for investors begins when an exchange suspends trading in a company’s shares indefinitely. For investors, the implications are the same as delisting— they cannot sell their shares.
Who is to blame?
On the face of it, the primary responsibility appears to lie with the stock exchange concerned as it is the platform where the funds are raised and the only direct link with the companies. So it would seem natural that it should track the companies regularly and ensure compliance with the requirements under the listing agreement, instead of mechanically suspending and delisting them.But, according to the BSE, “Before suspending companies which are non-compliant, we give adequate notice to the market and media (through releases and advertisements). The existing shareholders should track these notices issued by the exchange.”So the responsibility also lies with the investors, who need to play a proactive role by keeping a close tab on the companies they have invested in. As for the notice period, it is often inadequate. At present, exchanges don’t have to forewarn investors about suspensions. In some cases where a notification is issued, the standard 10 days’ period is not enough for the news to trickle down to investors or for them to act. Experts say there should be a longer period to give investors a chance to exit. The counter-argument is that the time doesn’t matter; those who track it will spot it, those who don’t will miss it anyway.
Collateral damage
One problem of holding on to dud stocks is that you cannot claim losses under “capital gains” as it is neither a transfer nor a sale of shares or extinguishment of right. Another problem is in closing the demat account. The depository participant can close your demat account only if you have zero balance and that is impossible as the companies have been delisted and you cannot sell or transfer the shares. It is possible to achieve zero balance if you rematerialise your shares, that is, re-convert to physical shares, but this option is no good either. As there is a high probability that the delisted company has disappeared, who will rematerialise your shares? Which means you have to keep paying for holding on to the stocks and the demat account.
What you can do
Once a company has been delisted, there is nothing much you can do. However, there is hope in case of companies that have been suspended for non-compliance. One, there is a chance that they will comply. Two, you can keep track of such companies and complain to the exchange to trace them and request compliance, especially if it has been suspended for a technical lapse. There is time enough to do so as the company is usually not delisted for a few years. However, once the company is put in the “unknown” (or untraceable companies) list, even that option is lost.
Suspensions can be revoked if a company falls in line, but most don’t and end up being delisted. A company can relist after a cooling-off period of two years and after meeting other requirements, but they rarely do so. Given these worst-case scenarios, try to avoid hitting this dead end.
Buy what you knowDespite being able to buy blue chips in small lots, many investors chase lowpriced stocks in the hope of big returns. Don’t invest in unknown, low-priced stocks unless you understand the associated risks—suspension and delisting being one of them—and are willing to put up with these. If not, stick to known companies that are good, running businesses and whose stock is traded in good numbers every day.
Track your stockIf you can’t resist taking a punt on penny stocks, at least track them. Given their obscure nature, you need to be more involved in this exercise than you would for frontline stocks. If a company doesn’t disclose its results or send you annual reports, or delays dividend payments, it could be headed for trouble. Stock exchange notices that haul up a company for violations are also warning signs. According to a BSE spokesperson, “The Sebi (Delisting of Securities) Guidelines 2003 provide an investor the right to claim compensation from the promoters. However, in their best interests, the investors have to monitor the quality of their investment constantly and take corrective measures before it is too late.”
Check with other stock exchangesIf the shares are delisted, check if they are also delisted from all the stock exchanges where they were initially offered. Usually, delisting first takes place from the optional stock exchanges, not from the regional stock exchanges.
Approach the regulatorAccording to Sebi’s delisting guidelines, promoters of defaulting companies are liable to buy shares from the investors wanting to exit. For this, you have to approach the exchange, which will appoint an arbitrator. After hearing you and the promoter, if present, he will decide the price at which the promoter has to buy your shares. Again, it’s good on paper, but not enforceable, as promoters can’t be tracked down and forced to pay up. Your best option is to avoid a ride with these fly-by-night firms.
Wait for a relistingIf the company is in good financial health and relists, the issue can be taken up again. DLF, for instance, delisted from BSE in 1982 citing an increase in listing fee, and from the DSE in September 2003. There were over 1,300 shareholders who continued to hold its shares. So when the company relisted, it was forced to listen to them and offer compensation.
There is no way of knowing that a company will vanish, but a little homework before investing helps. Barely 50% of investors rely on prospectus before investing, most basing their decisions on past issue performances or hearsay. They must take into account all available information to avoid the nasty surprise of being stuck with dud shares in a delisted company.